Autumnal Equinox 2009: The Fall of the Summer Reading List
I've been updating the status of various books on this list since shortly after I first published my 2009 Summer Reading List. This post is scheduled to be published at 5:18pm on the 22nd of September, the official start of Fall. Let's see how much reading I actually got done this summer...
Finished
- Shambling Towards Hiroshima by James Morrow.
Rating:




- The Touch by F. Paul Wilson.
Rating:




- Glasshouse by Charles Stross.
Rating:




- His Majesty's Dragon (Temeraire · Book 1) by Naomi Novik.
Rating:




- Anathem by Neal Stephenson (Audio; narrated by William Dufris).
Rating:




- Lamb by Christopher Moore.
Rating:




- Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell by Susanna Clarke (Audio; narrated by Simon Prebble).
Rating:




- The Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger.
Rating:




- The Strain by Guillermo del Toro and Chuck Hogan (Audio; narrated by Ron Perlman).
Rating:




- WWW: Wake by Robert J. Sawyer (Audio; various narrators).
Rating:




- Dead Witch Walking by Kim Harrison (Audio; narrated by Marguerite Gavin).
Rating:




- The Stepsister Scheme by Jim C. Hines.
Rating:




- Paranoia by Joseph Finder (Audio; narrated by Scott Brick).
Rating:




- Norse Code by Greg van Eekhout.
Rating:




- The Destroyer #14: Judgment Day by Warren Murphy and Richard Sapir.
Rating:




- The Way of Shadows by Brent Weeks.
Rating:




In Progress
- Saturn's Children by Charles Stross (Audio; narrated by Bianca Amato).
Not Yet Started
- Throne of Jade (Temeraire · Book 2) by Naomi Novik.
- Personal Effects: Dark Art by J.C. Hutchins and Jordan Weisman.
- Agent to the Stars by John Scalzi.
Not too shabby, overall. My peculiar flavor of attention deficit disorder came into play, as I expected it would, and I read or started to read several titles that weren't on the original list. I also failed to even start a handful from the original list, but maybe I'll get around to them this fall. Speaking of fall, here (in no particular order) is the 2009 Fall Reading List:
- Midnight's Children by Salman Rushdie (Audio; narrated by Lyndam Gregory).
- The Devil You Know by Mike Carey.
- Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson.
- Batman: The Stone King by Alan Grant.
- Black Powder War (Temeraire · Book 3) by Naomi Novik.
- Broken Crescent by S. Andrew Swann.
- Furies of Calderon (The Codex Alera · Book 1) by Jim Butcher.
- Fool Moon (The Dresden Files · Book 2) by Jim Butcher.
- Condemned to Repeat It: The Philospher Who Flunked Life and Other Great Lessons from History by Wick Allison, Jeremy Adams and Gavin Hambly.
- Ill Wind by Kevin J. Anderson and Doug Beason.
- The Two Faces of Tomorrow by James P. Hogan.
Dora the Explorer of the Rings
Someone has to say it: Dora the Explorer is a complete ripoff of The Lord of the Rings.
Let's review:
- Dora is a short person from a fantastical land who is called upon to deliver an item to a faraway place. On her journey (or quest), she must overcome a number of obstacles and often encounters strange creatures.
- Frodo Baggins is a short person from a fantastical land who is called upon to deliver an item (The One Ring) to a faraway place (The Cracks of Doom in Mordor). On his quest, he encounters strange creatures and must overcome a number of obstacles.
- Dora is accompanied by a loyal companion (also short) named Boots.
- Frodo Baggins is accompanied by a loyal companion (also short) named Samwise Gamgee.
- Dora is often joined by companions of different species: Isa the Iguana and Benny the Bull, to name two.
- Frodo Baggins is joined by companions of different races: Gimli the Dwarf and Legolas the Elf, to name two.
- Dora is pursued by Swiper the Fox, a conniving-yet-cowardly thief who wants to steal something she is carrying.
- Frodo Baggins is pursued by Gollum, a conniving-yet-cowardly thief who wants to steal The One Ring.
- Dora is eventually joined by Diego, an animal rescuer who is skilled at tracking and outdoor survival.
- Frodo Baggins is eventually joined by Aragorn, a ranger who is skilled at tracking and outdoor survival.
- Dora must often solve puzzles using words and phrases in another language (Spanish).
- Frodo Baggins was unable to enter the Mines of Moria until the word "friend" was spoken in another language (Elvish).
Of course, there are a few elements of Dora the Explorer that aren't ripped straight out of The Lord of the Rings...or are there? Let's consider:
- Dora has a magical backpack that contains whatever object she might need to solve a puzzle or overcome an obstacle. There's no magical backpack in The Lord of the Rings, but Dora's backpack sounds an awful lot like a Bag of Holding from the Dungeons & Dragons roleplaying game (which was around decades before Dora the Explorer), and everyone knows that Dungeons & Dragons is the King of All Lord of the Rings Ripoffs.
- Frodo Baggins is led by Gandalf, a wise old wizard who tells him which way to go and, ultimately, leads him into dire peril. Dora is rarely seen in the company of old men, wise or otherwise. True enough, but she does consult with a magical, talking map that tells her how to get to her destination, typically through waypoints that are fraught with peril (windy bridges, treacherous mountains, and the like). The Map may not be carrying a staff or wearing a pointy hat, but he definitely fills the "magical guide" role. ("Tell Frodo he has to go through the Mines of Moria, over the Fields of Pellenor and up Aman Amarth!")
I'm sure there will be naysayers; those who call this evidence "circumstantial" or "coincidental" and point out that "Nickelodeon" isn't really an anagram of "J.R.R. Tolkien". You know: nutjobs. But to the rest of you—those who can see Middle Earth in the unnamed South American country in which Dora resides—I extend an invitation to show me more. Peel the veil further back to expose more proof. What have I missed? What more is there?
Summer Reading List 2009
I'm taking a page from Ken Newquist's book (or rather, his blog and podcast) to present my Summer Reading List. As we're well into the season, the list includes books I've read since late June, those I am currently reading, and those I intend to read before summer comes to a close. The last of these three lists is—to put it lightly—mutable, as which book I pick up next is subject more to whim than design.
Pages Past
- Shambling Towards Hiroshima by James Morrow. During World War II, a B-movie actor is hired to play the part of a giant, fire-breathing lizard in order to convince the Japanese to surrender or have a trio of Godzilla-like creatures unleashed on their cities.
- The Touch by F. Paul Wilson. The third installment of The Adversary Cycle tells the tale of a doctor who suddenly gains the ability to heal with a touch. It wouldn't be a medical thriller if there weren't a terrible price to pay. This isn't my preferred genre, but I enjoyed The Keep and The Tomb, so I thought I'd continue the cycle; The Touch isn't anywhere near as creepy as its predecessors, but it's a pretty entertaining tale.
- Glasshouse by Charles Stross. In a far-flung future where technology makes changing your gender, race, and even species as commonplace as changing your shirt, and humanity has been through a great Censorship War, Robin wakes with no memory of his past and a killer on his tail. How much of what makes you you is determined by your physical being, your memories, and your relationships with other people? This was really a fascinating read.

His Majesty's Dragon (Temeraire · Book 1) by Naomi Novik. During the Napoleonic Wars, the H.M.S. Reliant, a British naval vessel, captures a French ship and siezes a most unusual cargo: a dragon's egg. When the dragon hatches and bonds to Will Laurence, the Reliant's captain must leave the Navy behind for His Majesty's Air Corps. I love Novik's writing style and the relationship that forms between the dragon, Temeraire, and Laurence is beautifully executed. This is definitely my favorite book of the summer so far.
- Anathem (Audio) by Neal Stephenson. The audio version of this lengthy tome consists of twenty-eight compact discs and took me eleven weeks to complete. As Chris Miller pointed out to me, Neal Stephenson doesn't so much write novels as essays stitched together with bits of story. Much time is spent explaining how the world in which Anathem takes place is different from our own, complete with excerpts from The Dictionary (4th Edition, A.R. 3000) that mark the beginning of each of the eleventy-three thousillion chapters. Anathem follows Fraa Erasmas of the concent of Saunt Edhar as he ventures out into the sæcular world during (and after) Apert. And to explain every term in that sentence would require more space than I'm willing to devote to a single bullet point right now.
Pages Present

Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ's Childhood Pal by Christopher Moore. The Bible doesn't go into a whole lot of detail where the first thirty years of Christ's life are concerned, and now Levi (who is called Biff) has been resurrected by the angel Raziel to fill in the gaps. Chris Miller and I will be discussing this somewhat-apocryphal gospel on a future episode of The Secret Lair.
- The Strain (Audio) by Guillermo del Toro and Chuck Hogan. Vampires!
- Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell (Audio) by Susanna Clarke. Magicians!
- The Way of Shadows (Book 1 of The Night Angel Trilogy) by Brent Weeks. Assassins! (Sorry: wetboys.)
Pages Future

The Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger. Chronal Displacement Disorder!
- Throne of Jade (Temeraire · Book 2) by Naomi Novik. Dragons!
- WWW: Wake (Audio) by Robert J. Sawyer. Artificial Intelligence!
- Dead Witch Walking (Audio) by Kim Harrison.
- Agent to the Stars by John Scalzi. Aliens!
- Personal Effects: Dark Art by J.C. Hutchins and Jordan Weisman. Serial Killers!
Finally, here is a fourth list, which may be considered a bonus by some and entirely excessive by others. I have been using GoodReads to track my ever-expanding library and hummingbirdlike reading habits, but there are a number of similar sites and as I become aware of one I can't help but set up an account and import at least a portion of my books, just to see how it compares to the others. Here is a list of said sites (I don't claim it is comprehensive, and if you know of another please leave a comment with a link to it.) that I've been using recently, in the order I joined:
- GoodReads. Very well put together. The interface is generally very intuitive, though management of group "shelves" could be enhanced. GoodReads is, unfortunately, ad-supported.
- Readernaut. My favorite of the bunch so far. Pages aren't as "busy" as those on GoodReads or LibraryThing and there's a lot of flexibility around tweaking books (I especially like that I can upload my own cover images). Pages tend to render poorly on some installations of Internet Explorer. Readernaut is not currently ad-supported.
- Shelfari. My least favorite by quite a large margin. I'm not a fan of the default "shelf" layout and though the add/edit book interface is nice and streamlined, it is also rather limited. Shelfari is ad-supported.
- LibraryThing. I haven't played with this one very much, but I do like that there is space for BookCrossing IDs (though it's been months since I last logged in to BookCrossing) and they seem to pack in a lot of information about individual titles. LibraryThing is not ad-supported, but offers both free and subscription-based models, so I can only assume that the size of my library (as a free user) has a limit.
Bookstuff: Murder at Avedon Hill by P.G. Holyfield
Want to know how long it's taken P.G. Holyfield to complete the audio version of his novel, Murder at Avedon Hill? Let me put it this way: I do one of the voices in the podcast novel and partway through the process I had to re-record all of my lines because puberty hit and my voice broke.
Yes, it's been a long time coming.1
But persistence (on the part of Holyfield) and patience (on the part of his 13,000+ fans) has certainly paid off. Yesterday, P.G. announced that Murder at Avedon Hill has been picked up by Dragon Moon Press and will be published late this year.
Here's a snippet from the official press release:
“With what he’s done with his podcast, P.G Holyfield was on our radar,” notes Gwen Gades, publisher at Dragon Moon Press. “But fans tracking down a publisher to request the print version of the novel? We had to move on that.”
Now, I'm not one to encourage what amounts to stalking, but I suppose there are worse things a publisher could say about an author than "his fans demanded that we publish the book."
Murder at Avedon Hill: A Land of Caern Novel tells the story of Arames Kragen, a monk who finds himself on the hunt for a killer in the town of Avedon Hill. Young Gretta Platt, Housemistress of Avedon Manor has been murdered, and Arames must bring her killer to justice before Lord Avedon will allow the monk access to the only pass through the Lantis Mountains. Solving the murder is challenge enough, but Caern is a world where gods walk among mortals and fantastical creatures are often more than the stuff of fairy tale and legend. Arames Kragen will need all his wits about him to find the killer...or even just to survive.
- At the time of this writing, it's still a long time coming, as there are two episodes yet to be released. [back]
